
This is a brilliant suspense story! The tension builds perfectly as Melanie’s paranoia escalates, leading her — and us — down a path of questions about her own mind and safety. The reveal about carbon dioxide poisoning is unexpected yet plausible, adding an eerie layer that’s grounded in reality. Ron’s concern and eventual support provide a warm, stabilizing influence, which rounds out the story beautifully.
Your use of sensory details, like the smell of burning toast or the creak of an old apartment, really pulls readers into Melanie’s deteriorating world. The way you weave in her fascination with true crime as a potential factor in her confusion is a clever touch, and the notes turning out to be her own under the effects of CO2 deprivation is the perfect twist.
The additional story teaser at the end for Trent’s story is intriguing too! It would draw readers into another layer of mystery. This story really nails the suspense while maintaining a sympathetic, relatable protagonist.
Four Years after My Husband Went Missing, a Dog Brought Me the Jacket He Was Wearing on the Day He Disappeared

Maggie had mourned her husband Jason for four years, believing he was lost in the wilderness, until their old dog, Scout, returned carrying Jason’s worn jacket. This unexpected sign filled her with hope and drove her to follow Scout deep into the forest. She could never have prepared for what she’d find.
In the fading daylight, Scout led her to a hidden cabin, and inside was Jason, alive and seemingly well—living a new life with a woman named Sarah. Jason greeted her with a calm, unsettling indifference, explaining that he’d found “something real” here. His rehearsed words unraveled Maggie’s years of grief into raw betrayal. She’d raised their children alone, clinging to his memory, only to learn he had chosen to abandon them.
Without another word, she turned away from the man she no longer knew, her heart hardened by his betrayal. The next morning, she took control of her future, sitting across from a lawyer to finalize the end of her marriage and demand support for their children. Reclaiming her life, Maggie resolved to forge a path built on love, resilience, and integrity, moving forward without a single glance back.
Leave a Reply